Humanizing the criminal justice system
Kerman speaks about her prison experience, criminal justice reform
An unusual mix of social justice advocates and Netflix binge-watchers gathered in Gasson 100 last February to hear Piper Kerman, author of Orange Is the New Black and inspiration for the TV series of the same name, deliver the annual Chambers Lecture. She discussed her prison experience and prison reform advocacy.
Kerman served 13 months in a federal prison for carrying a bag of illicitly acquired money from Chicago to Brussels. Incarcerated in Connecticut, she found on her first day that as a new inmate she could not buy basic hygiene products like toothpaste from the commissary. “You are completely reliant on the kindness of strangers,” Kerman said. “And the last thing I expected on my first day of prison was to experience kindness at the hands of the other women there.”
She noted the utilitarian prison infrastructure, praising her ward’s “resident artist” for making decorative name tags for her fellow inmates’ bunks. Kerman appreciated her attention to aesthetic detail as well as the assertion that their names were more important than their numbers. “American prisons and jails are very intentionally built and operated to be incredibly harsh, punitive, difficult places to exist,” Kerman said. “That is part of the American idea of punishment—not corrections, but punishment.”
Nearing the end of her sentence, Kerman and other inmates were transported from Connecticut to a Chicago facility via jumbo jets. Kerman emphasized the degrading restraints inmates endured as well as the prison system’s bias against marginalized populations. “You see vastly disproportionately black and brown people, you see people of every age, you see people from many walks of life,” Kerman said. “And what you hear is the rattling of chains as you are transported from one facility to another.”
In addition to noting the racial composition of inmates, Kerman discussed the increasing incidence of women’s incarceration over time. She remarked that over the last 40 years, the incarceration rate for women has increased by 650 percent—the male incarceration rate increased 400 percent. She also highlighted the profound impacts of incarceration on inmates’ lives, including homecoming barriers to relationships and social opportunities. She condemned the United States for its imprisonment philosophy of punishment rather than reform, citing historical examples of punitive oppression, like chattel slavery and the displacement of indigenous peoples. “I think that our commitment to harsh punishment, tolerance of it, [and] our embrace of it has very deep roots in this country and we have to contend with that if we ever want to do better,” Kerman said.
She detailed systematic changes that she advocates for, including common-sense prison reform—which is geared toward simplifying and, in the opinion of its advocates, humanizing the criminal justice system—jail and court reform, and better care for children in the system. She said that her personal contact with women inmates helped her to see the potential for empathy and solidarity in the face of oppression. “It is that connection to one another that helps us to understand our own power in the world and helps us to make better choices about how to use our power in the world to make good choices, instead of doing harm,” Kerman said.
Adapted from an article by Becky Reilly ’19 in The Heights, February 27, 2019.